Frequent Glitches in Accounting, Tax, Foreign exchange Administration of FIEs in China

By Amber Liu, Dezan Shira & Associates’ Shenzhen Place of work

Editor: Qian Zhou

For international-invested enterprises (FIEs) operating in China, it is not uncommon to see that a host of problematic challenges get disclosed in the yr-end audit. Accounting, tax treatment, and international trade administration are amid the most slip-up-inclined regions for this kind of entities.

In this write-up, we checklist out some of the most typical errors observed in FIEs, to help corporations improve their interior finance processes, get the most out of their annual audit, and why it is vital to secure tips from skilled company vendors.

Tax treatment method

Maximizing tax efficiency when protecting compliance with tax legal guidelines and regulations is constantly a person of the priorities for international buyers. On the other hand, FIEs could continue to undergo because of to underpayment or overpayment of taxes due to carelessness or incomplete data.

In the case of tax underpayment, the FIE will have to make supplementary tax payments with opportunity late costs and fines. The tax ranking of the FIE may possibly also get influenced. The bill application and other tax matters could possibly be influenced as well.

Illustrations of typical errors

Some regular examples observed are talked about under.

1) Glitches brought about by lack of in depth knowledge of China’s tax system: Some FIEs have underpaid tax mainly because their accountants do not have an sufficient knowing of China’s tax laws and restrictions, especially when cross-border transactions are included. For illustration, when an abroad shareholder of the Chinese subsidiary transfers the equity of the corporation to other folks, the transferor could fail to shell out income tax in China for the gain received from the share transfer. One more illustration is, when the domestic corporation pays royalties or service service fees overseas, it fails to deduct withholding value-extra tax (VAT) and income tax in accordance to the tax guidelines.

2) Failing to pay out stamp tax: Stamp tax is billed at a relatively very low rate of .005 p.c to .1 % on legal documents, this kind of as contracts, certificates, and accounting publications, and all signing functions affiliated with a agreement are legally obliged to pay back stamp duty. However, some FIEs frequently are unsuccessful to declare stamp tax for rental contracts, transportation contracts, etc.

3) Failing to file VAT for non-invoiced income: Companies are expected to declare VAT in the sort of “uninvoicing revenue” when they have done organization and verified revenue, even if the invoices have not been issued.

4) Failing to file tax returns right before deadlines: For illustration, the deadline for paying out corporate income tax (CIT) is in 15 days of the stop of just about every thirty day period or quarter. Tax declaration produced afterwards than that will immediately lead to a late rate at .05 per cent on a lot less-paid out tax for each day and a different high-quality, the amount of which is made the decision by the tax bureau scenario by situation. At the exact same time, the enterprise’s tax credit rating will lessen, and when it is minimized to a specific degree, the tax credit rating rating of the FIE will be downgraded by the tax bureau.

5) Failing to fully delight in the tax incentives: China gives quite a few tax and payment reduction policies to assistance organizations, these types of as the earnings tax preferential coverage for little and minimal-financial gain enterprises, the reduced CIT charge for superior-tech enterprises, CIT deductions for R&D expenses, etcetera. Aside from, China lets a selected quantity of fees to be deducted ahead of shelling out tax. And FIEs are usually found not possessing completely utilised these incentives.

6) Failure to establish a realistic tax system for the FIE: In other phrases, raising the FIE’s tax burdens or leading to higher tax challenges thanks to inadequate scheduling or abnormal organizing. For case in point, for the duration of a share transfer, there are suitable techniques to reduce the over-all tax charge, and tax deferral is also available for specific firms, all of which could be totally neglected by inexperienced company companies who are not acquainted with the issue. The case in point of aggressive tax organizing can be observed as follows – an imprudent services provider may perhaps wrongfully use the preferential tax charge for the FIEs’ gain distribution to international shareholders, whilst the FIE, in truth, fails to meet the conditions for making the most of the preferential tax procedures. This is quick to establish in the common investigations done by respective tax bureaus, and can direct to late fee charged at .05 per cent of the payable total.


Accounting and bookkeeping in China are governed by the Chinese Accounting Criteria (CAS), also identified as the Chinese Normally Recognized Accounting Concepts (Chinese GAAP). When getting ready money reviews in yearly audit, some normal problems are typically noticed in FIEs’ accounting publications and economical documentation that are not in line with the Chinese GAAP, which will have an affect on the afterwards economical reporting and details examination, and may possibly lead to tax losses indirectly when not able to deduct certain expenditures due to unqualified accounting and bookkeeping.

Examples of common problems

Some examples of typical errors in this region are talked about beneath:

1) Failing to preserve complete authentic paperwork that really should be attached to the accounting vouchers, primary to failure in pre-tax deduction of applicable fees. For instance, some accounting entries are not supported by pertinent fapiao/invoices, or the fapiao hooked up does not match the sum demonstrated on the accounting publications or, only the lender statements are preserved, whilst the bank memos/slips are missing. According to the tax principles, without comprehensive and appropriate fapiao and other supporting files, the expenses accrued by enterprises are not able to be deducted from profits when calculating gross earnings, which will directly impact the CIT calculation.

2) Failing to stick to the accrual foundation of accounting principles in performing recognition, measurement, and reporting for accounting reasons. For case in point, some charges are not recorded in a timely way, or some profits is not identified in time.

3) Unable to change and employ the new accounting criteria for money statements in the prescribed time. In modern yrs, China has constantly been revising its accounting requirements to minimize discrepancies with International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS). For illustration, the revised CAS No.16 on “government subsidy” arrived into result in January 2017, and the revised CAS No.7 on “exchange of non-monetary assets” took result in June 2019.
What’s more, a few revised CAS expectations on revenue, leases, and financial instruments will get impact in January 2021 – for all entities that have by now adopted the Chinese Accounting Requirements for Business Enterprises. In these circumstances, in which the regional finance team fails to capture up with the most recent developments, the new CAS standards may perhaps not be utilized effectively.

4) Failing to make obvious explanations to the headquarters (HQ) thanks to insufficient or bad communication when HQ conducts facts analysis and consolidates statements, thereby resulting in the group’s incapability to have a crystal clear understanding of China’s fiscal predicament.

Foreign exchange

All foreign trade transactions in and out of China are strictly controlled by the Condition Administration of Foreign Trade (Harmless), the bureau underneath the central financial institution of China – the People’s Bank of China. And there are a sequence of formalities for FIEs to comply with when involving overseas currencies. Failing to comply with related requirements may bring about an additional inspection from Protected or direct to the failure to acquire the resources in overseas trade.

Illustrations of popular faults

Some widespread faults in the area of international exchange administration are observed below:

1) Failing to properly categorize the character of the international cash obtained by the FIE from overseas, declaring the overseas exchange funds that really should be place below funds account into trade account, or vice versa.

China divides overseas forex transactions into two independent classes: all those beneath the latest account (trade and support goods) and those people below the cash account (expenditure, financial loans, etcetera.). It is important for FIEs to properly define the character of cash and continue with related formalities appropriately.

In some cases where by the abroad investors want to remit a significant quantity of overseas trade to their China subsidiaries in a short interval of time, they may well wrongfully declare the fund as advance payment, which will be categorized beneath the trade account rather of the capital account, to avoid the formalities of increasing registered capital with the current market regulation department, Harmless, and the banks.

Theoretically, the international exchange collection/payment information and the import/export declaration records must be commonly consistent, and the big difference should really be saved inside a acceptable array. If the cash are declared as advance payment, they will be regarded as income volume, which will typically far exceed the frequent revenue of the Chinese entity in standard months. This will get reflected as irregular records in the overseas trade assortment and payment method maintained by Risk-free.

In such conditions, the Secure may perhaps perform on-site investigations on the FIE and pass the data to the tax authority at the same time. And the tax authority may well consider the larger-than-normal advance payment as concealed money of the FIE, requiring the FIE to history it as sales money, and paying out CIT, late fee, and penalties accordingly.

It is as a result recommended that the abroad finance crew ought to talk with China’s finance workforce in advance when generating cross-border money arrangements for Chinese subsidiaries. The Chinese finance group need to meticulously comprehend the background and the character of the money, and make important preparations to meet regulatory formalities to make positive it can be obtained in time, and induce no more tax burdens, result in penalties, or final result in incompliance.

2) Failing to comply with the formality needs posed by the banking companies and the Safe. There are formalities to go by means of for obtaining specified resources, which FIEs may are unsuccessful to observe when taking care of international trade. For illustration, when overseas funds need to be compensated to China in the type of loans, the Chinese subsidiary desires to go through methods, this kind of as overseas exchange registration with Safe, before the bank can receive the cash. The FIE will not be ready to get the funds otherwise.

To avoid remaining guilty of committing these frequently noticed mistakes or starting to be incompliant due to negligence or circumventing guidelines thanks to time taken to meet up with formalities, FIEs are recommended to give superior-quality teaching to their interior finance crew routinely or use certified qualified third-party products and services who are acquainted with these error-inclined parts.

For much more information and facts, you are welcome to down load our brochure on Internal Audit, Danger, and Compliance, or email us at [email protected].

About Us

China Briefing is created and made by Dezan Shira & Associates. The practice helps overseas investors into China and has finished so since 1992 by way of offices in Beijing, Tianjin, Dalian, Qingdao, Shanghai, Hangzhou, Ningbo, Suzhou, Guangzhou, Dongguan, Zhongshan, Shenzhen, and Hong Kong. Remember to speak to the business for assistance in China at [email protected] 

We also maintain places of work assisting overseas buyers in Vietnam, Indonesia, Singapore, The Philippines, MalaysiaThailand, United States, and Italy, in addition to our tactics in India and Russia and our trade investigation services together the Belt & Highway Initiative.